Texas · Auto insurance
How to Choose a Car Insurance Deductible You Can Live With
A deductible is a bet you make with yourself: a lower bill every month against a bigger bill on a bad day. This guide shows how to run the numbers and pick an amount you will not regret at the body shop.

In short
Choose the highest deductible you could pay this week without borrowing, then check that the premium you save is worth the extra risk. Divide the extra deductible by the yearly savings to see how many claim-free years it takes to break even. A deductible applies to each comprehensive or collision claim, never to liability, so set each one for the losses most likely where you drive and park.
- A deductible is the part of each comprehensive or collision claim you pay yourself. Liability claims have none.
- A higher deductible lowers the premium, but only for the coverages that carry a deductible.
- Break-even years = extra deductible divided by yearly premium savings.
- Comprehensive and collision deductibles are chosen separately and do not have to match.
- You owe no deductible on a claim against the at-fault driver's insurance company.
In this article
- What exactly is a deductible, and when do you pay it?
- Which coverages have a deductible, and which do not?
- How much does a higher deductible really save?
- How do you find your break-even point?
- Should your comprehensive and collision deductibles match?
- When do you not pay a deductible, or get it back?
- What deductible mistakes cost people the most?
- How do you pick your number, step by step?
Your quote shows the same policy at three prices, and the only thing that changes is the deductible. The right choice is the highest amount you could pay this week without borrowing, as long as the premium you save is worth the extra risk. The steps below show how to test both halves of that sentence.
What exactly is a deductible, and when do you pay it?
The Insurance Information Institute defines a deductible as the amount of money you are responsible for paying toward an insured loss. The company subtracts it from the claim payment.
The Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) gives a simple example: on a $1,500 collision claim with a $500 deductible, the company pays $1,000. You cover the other $500, usually by paying the repair shop when the work is done.
Three details matter more than people expect:
- It applies to each claim. The Insurance Information Institute notes that on an auto policy the deductible applies every time you file, not once a year.
- It is a dollar amount. Auto deductibles are flat dollar figures. Percentage deductibles are mainly a homeowners feature, which we explain in how a wind and hail percentage deductible works.
- It is printed on your declarations page, next to each coverage that has one. If that page is new to you, the insurance glossary explains the terms on it.
Which coverages have a deductible, and which do not?
A deductible does not touch every part of your auto policy. TDI says you pay one for collision, comprehensive, and uninsured or underinsured motorist claims. The Insurance Information Institute adds that deductibles generally do not apply to the liability portion.
Where a deductible applies on a typical Texas auto policy
| Coverage | Deductible? | What to know |
|---|---|---|
| Liability (bodily injury and property damage) | No | Pays other people from the first dollar, up to your limits |
| Collision | Yes, you choose it | Applies to each crash claim on your own car |
| Comprehensive | Yes, you choose it | Applies to each hail, theft, flood, fire or animal claim |
| Uninsured/underinsured motorist property damage | Yes | The Office of Public Insurance Counsel lists a $250 deductible |
| A claim against the at-fault driver's company | No | TDI: you do not pay a deductible on another driver's insurance |
What this means for you: changing your deductible only changes the price of comprehensive and collision. If most of your premium is liability and other coverages, a higher deductible will move the total less than you hope.
If you are not sure what those two coverages do, start with comprehensive vs. collision coverage, then come back to set the amounts.
How much does a higher deductible really save?
TDI puts the principle in one line: the higher your deductible, the lower your premium. You take on more of each loss, so the company charges less.
How much less depends on the company, the car and the driver. As a general guide, the Insurance Information Institute says that raising a deductible from $200 to $500 could reduce collision and comprehensive costs by 15 to 30 percent, and that going to $1,000 can save 40 percent or more. Those percentages apply only to the collision and comprehensive part of the bill, not the whole premium.
Treat that as a starting point and ask for your real numbers. A quote can be run at several deductibles, and the savings are not the same at every step. Ask to see each step priced, with comprehensive and collision shown separately.
A deductible is one of several levers. For the others, see how to lower your car insurance in Dallas–Fort Worth without gutting your coverage.
How do you find your break-even point?
The break-even point tells you how long you must go without a claim before a higher deductible has paid for itself. The formula is short:
Extra deductible ÷ yearly premium savings = years to break even
Here is a worked example with round numbers. It is an illustration, not a quote.
Maria in Plano has a $500 collision deductible. Her agent prices the same policy with a $1,000 deductible, and the collision premium drops by $120 a year. The extra risk she takes on is $500 per claim. $500 divided by $120 is about 4.2 years.
If Maria goes more than four years between collision claims, the higher deductible wins. If she has a claim in year two, she saved $240 in premium and paid $500 more at the shop, so she is $260 behind.
Years to break even when you raise a deductible by $500 (example savings)
| Yearly premium savings | Extra you pay per claim | Years to break even |
|---|---|---|
| $50 | $500 | 10 years |
| $100 | $500 | 5 years |
| $125 | $500 | 4 years |
| $250 | $500 | 2 years |
What this means for you: if the break-even is longer than the time you usually go between claims, or longer than you plan to keep the car, the higher deductible is not a good trade. If it is two or three years and you have a clean record, it probably is.
Be honest about your own history. A daily commute on I-35E or the Bush Turnpike, street parking, or a new driver in the house all make a claim more likely.
Should your comprehensive and collision deductibles match?
They do not have to, and in North Texas there is a good reason to think about them separately.
Collision claims are mostly about how and how much you drive. Comprehensive claims are mostly about where the car sits. Hail, a fallen limb, theft and high water do not care how careful you are, and spring hail is a regular event across Denton, Collin and Dallas counties. A car parked outside is exposed every storm season.
That leads to a common pattern: a lower deductible on comprehensive, where a claim is more likely to be outside your control, and a higher one on collision if your driving record is clean and you have savings. It is a pattern, not a rule. Price both ways.
Two more points to weigh:
- Small glass and hail claims. A deductible higher than the repair bill means the coverage pays nothing for that loss. See whether to file a cracked windshield claim and how a hail damage claim on your car works.
- Your home deductible in the same storm. One hailstorm can damage the roof and the car on the same afternoon. That is two policies and two deductibles due at once, and the home deductible is often a percentage of the home's insured value. Add the two together before you decide what you can afford. Our home insurance page explains that side.
When do you not pay a deductible, or get it back?
There are situations where the deductible never comes out of your pocket, or comes back later.
- The other driver is at fault and their company pays. TDI says you do not pay a deductible for claims against another driver's insurance company.
- You use your own collision coverage and your company recovers the money. If the other insurer delays or refuses, you can file with your own company and pay your deductible. TDI says your company will usually try to recover the money, and if it does, you will probably get your deductible back.
- The at-fault driver has no insurance. With uninsured motorist property damage coverage, the deductible is $250 according to the Office of Public Insurance Counsel, which is often lower than a collision deductible. Read more in whether uninsured motorist coverage is worth it in Texas.
- Someone else is hurt or their property is damaged and you are at fault. That is a liability claim, and no deductible applies.
One caution. Be wary of any repair shop that offers to make your deductible disappear. Your company subtracts the deductible from what it pays, and TDI's storm guidance is clear that you owe that amount to the shop. An estimate padded to hide it puts false information in front of your insurance company.
What deductible mistakes cost people the most?
- Choosing by premium alone. The cheapest quote often carries the highest deductible. Compare quotes at the same deductible first.
- Picking a number you cannot pay. If the deductible would go on a credit card at a high interest rate, the premium savings are gone.
- Forgetting it applies per claim. Two claims in one year means paying it twice.
- Never revisiting it. A deductible chosen when money was tight may be too low now, and one chosen for a new car may be too high for a car that has lost much of its value. When a car is worth little more than the deductible, the coverage itself is the question: see full coverage vs. liability-only car insurance.
- Ignoring the loan or lease. If the car is financed or leased, read the contract or ask the lender whether it sets a maximum deductible before you raise yours.
- Filing every small claim. Claims can affect what you pay at renewal. We explain that in why car insurance goes up in Texas.
How do you pick your number, step by step?
- Find your current deductibles. Look at the declarations page for each car. Note the comprehensive and collision amounts separately.
- Set your ceiling. Write down the amount you could pay this week from savings without borrowing. Your deductible should not be higher than that.
- Check the loan or lease. Ask whether the contract limits the deductible.
- Get the price at each level. Ask for the same policy at two or three deductibles, with comprehensive and collision shown separately.
- Run the break-even. Divide the extra deductible by the yearly savings. Compare the answer to how often you have had claims and how long you will keep the car.
- Set money aside. If you raise the deductible, put that amount in savings and leave it there. The premium you save can refill it after a claim.
Review the choice at each renewal, after you pay off the car, and when a new driver joins the policy. Deductibles are one part of the larger picture on our auto insurance page.
How Assured Insurance Group helps
Assured Insurance Group helps drivers in Flower Mound, Plano, Garland and across Dallas–Fort Worth with auto insurance, as well as home and personal, commercial and life insurance. We will walk through your current policy with you, show you the deductibles you have today, and go over your options at different deductible levels. You can call, email info@assuredinsgroup.com, or stop by our Plano office. To get started, request a quote or call 214-222-5234.
Questions people ask next
Is a $500 or a $1,000 deductible better?
Neither is better for everyone. A $1,000 deductible lowers your premium, but you carry an extra $500 of risk on every claim. Ask for the price both ways, divide $500 by the yearly savings, and see how many years without a claim it takes to come out ahead. If you could not pay $1,000 this week without borrowing, the lower deductible is the safer choice.
Do I pay my deductible if the accident was not my fault?
Not if the other driver's insurance company pays. The Texas Department of Insurance says you do not pay a deductible for claims against another driver's insurance company. If you use your own collision coverage instead, you pay your deductible up front. Your company will usually try to recover its money from the other insurer, and if it does, you will probably get your deductible back.
Who do I actually pay the deductible to?
Usually the repair shop. Your insurance company subtracts the deductible from the claim payment, and you pay that amount to the shop when you pick up the car. If the car is a total loss, the company subtracts the deductible from the settlement check instead, so you never write a separate check for it.
Does the deductible apply once a year or on every claim?
On every claim. The Insurance Information Institute explains that on auto and homeowners policies the deductible applies each time you file a claim. Two separate hailstorms in one spring are two comprehensive claims and two deductibles. That is one reason to choose an amount you could pay more than once in a rough year.
Can I change my deductible in the middle of the policy term?
Ask your agent or company. Companies set their own rules on mid-term changes, and when a change is allowed the premium is adjusted to match. A new deductible applies only to losses that happen afterward: you cannot lower a deductible after the hail has already fallen. If the car is financed or leased, check your contract before raising it.
Is there a deductible on uninsured motorist coverage in Texas?
Yes, on the property damage part. The Office of Public Insurance Counsel says uninsured and underinsured motorist property damage coverage has a $250 deductible. If you carry both collision and uninsured motorist property damage, you can choose which one to use, or use both if one alone is not enough.
Sources and further reading
- Insurance Information Institute: Understanding your insurance deductibles
- Insurance Information Institute: Nine ways to lower your auto insurance costs
- Texas Department of Insurance: Auto insurance guide
- Texas Department of Insurance: Texas auto insurance FAQ
- Office of Public Insurance Counsel: Auto insurance basics
- Texas Department of Insurance: Hail damage to your home or car? What to do next
General information for Texas readers, current as of October 2026. It is not legal, tax or insurance advice. Your coverage depends on the wording of your own policy.
More auto insurance guides
- Do You Need Gap Insurance on a Financed or Leased Car in Texas?
- SR-22 Insurance in Texas: What It Is, Who Needs It and How Long
- What Happens If You Drive Without Insurance in Texas?
- Does Your Car Insurance Cover Someone Else Driving Your Car in Texas?
- Do You Need the Rental Car Company's Insurance If You Have Your Own Policy?
- Rideshare Insurance in Texas: What Uber and Lyft Drivers Need to Know



