Flower Mound (214) 222-5234·Plano·Garland info@assuredinsgroup.com

Texas · Commercial insurance

The Business Insurance Premium Audit: Why You Got a Bill After the Policy Ended

A premium audit compares what you guessed your payroll or sales would be with what they actually were. Here is which policies are audited, what the auditor asks for, how subcontractors change the result and what to do if the bill looks wrong.

Stack of record binders and a calculator on an office desk
Stack of record binders and a calculator on an office desk. Photo: Pexels

In short

Many business policies are priced on an estimate of your payroll, sales or units for the coming year, so the premium you pay up front is a deposit. After the policy ends, the insurer reviews your records to find the real figure. If it was higher than the estimate, you owe additional premium. If it was lower, you may be due a return premium.

  • The premium paid at the start of an auditable policy is a deposit based on estimated payroll, sales or units sold.
  • General liability and workers' compensation are the policies most often audited, usually after the term ends.
  • Payments to subcontractors without proof of their own insurance are a common cause of a large audit bill.
  • You can dispute an audit. Texas insurers must give policyholders a written notice of the procedure for a premium dispute.
  • Updating your estimate during the year is the simplest way to avoid a surprise at the end.

In this article

  1. Why did you get a bill after the policy ended?
  2. Which business policies are audited, and on what basis?
  3. What does the auditor actually look at?
  4. How do subcontractors change your audit?
  5. How does the math work in a real audit?
  6. What can you do if the audit is wrong?
  7. What happens if you ignore the audit or understate your payroll?
  8. How do you avoid a surprise next year?

Service: Commercial Insurance in Flower Mound, Plano and Garland

Your policy expired months ago, you paid every installment, and now an invoice has arrived for more premium. In most cases it is not a mistake or a penalty. The price you paid was based on an estimate, the insurer has now checked your real numbers, and the bill is the difference.

Why did you get a bill after the policy ended?

Many business policies cannot be priced exactly on day one, because the thing being insured is a year of activity that has not happened yet. So the insurer asks you to estimate it.

The Texas Department of Insurance explains that the premium paid at the start of an auditable general liability policy is a deposit, or estimated, premium. These policies usually use estimated payroll, sales or units sold as the premium base. The insurer is entitled to examine your books and records to find the actual figure, usually after the policy expires, though it can happen during the term.

The result goes one of two ways. If your actual payroll, sales or units were greater than the estimate, you may owe additional premium. If they were less, you may be due a return premium. The department's advice is to estimate as accurately as you can and to budget for a possible audit charge.

A premium audit is not a tax audit and has nothing to do with the IRS. It is a pricing true-up between you and your insurance company.

Which business policies are audited, and on what basis?

Not every policy is auditable. A policy is audited when its price depends on a number that moves during the year, which the industry calls the exposure basis. You can find more terms like this in our insurance glossary.

Common auditable policies and what they are measured on

PolicyUsual exposure basisRecords the auditor asks for
General liabilityPayroll, sales or units sold, depending on the type of businessPayroll reports, sales records, subcontractor payments
Workers' compensationPayroll, split by job classificationPayroll by employee, tax filings, job duties, overtime
Liquor liabilityUsually alcohol salesSales reports separating alcohol from food
Garage and auto fleetsPayroll, number of employees or vehicle countEmployee lists, vehicle schedules
TruckingOften mileage, revenue or number of unitsMileage and revenue reports, driver lists

What this means for you: look at your declarations page for the words premium basis, estimated exposure or subject to audit. Whatever number is printed there is the number you will be measured against, so check it the day the policy arrives, not the day the auditor calls.

The basis depends on what kind of business you run. A contractor's general liability policy is commonly rated on payroll, while a store or restaurant is more often rated on sales. For workers' compensation, the Insurance Information Institute notes that premiums start with your industry classification and your payroll, which is why both get checked.

Personal policies do not work this way. Your home policy and your personal auto insurance are priced for the term, with no audit at the end.

What does the auditor actually look at?

Audits are done by mail, by phone, online or in person, depending on the size of the policy. The request is usually the same set of documents. Have these ready for the exact policy period:

  • Payroll records by employee, including job duties
  • Quarterly payroll tax reports for the periods the policy covers
  • A sales or revenue report, if the policy is rated on sales
  • Your general ledger or check register, showing payments to subcontractors and casual labor
  • Certificates of insurance for every subcontractor you paid
  • A list of owners and officers and their roles
  • Details of any overtime paid

Two points are worth knowing before the conversation starts. The Insurance Information Institute advises employers to check that the insurer's payroll computation adjusts for overtime pay and that each employee's payroll is allocated to the right classification. An office manager and a roofer should not be priced the same way.

For workers' compensation, Texas law also puts a duty on you. Insurance Code Section 2051.101 requires a policyholder to fully disclose to its insurance company information about its payroll, operations and ownership.

How do subcontractors change your audit?

This is the single largest source of audit surprises for contractors and trades in Dallas–Fort Worth.

If you pay a subcontractor who has their own insurance and you can prove it, that payment is generally treated more favorably than your own payroll. If you cannot prove it, the auditor will usually add what you paid them to your exposure, as though they were your employees. The Insurance Information Institute notes that most states will treat an uninsured contractor or subcontractor, or their employees, as your employees, which is why larger companies require proof of coverage.

The proof is a certificate of insurance. To protect yourself:

  • Collect a certificate before the subcontractor starts work, not at audit time.
  • Check that the policy dates cover the whole period they worked for you.
  • Check that it shows the coverage being audited. A general liability certificate does not prove workers' compensation.
  • Keep certificates in one folder by policy year.

Texas adds a wrinkle, because most private employers here may choose not to carry workers' compensation. Many of your subcontractors will have none. How that affects you is explained in workers' compensation in Texas, and the wider list of what trades are asked to carry is in contractor insurance in Texas.

How does the math work in a real audit?

Here is an example with round numbers. The rate is chosen only to make the arithmetic easy. It is not a quote or a typical price.

A remodeling company in Plano buys a general liability policy rated on payroll. For the example, assume a rate of $20 for every $1,000 of payroll.

Example: estimated premium compared with audited premium

StepPayroll countedPremium at $20 per $1,000
Estimate at the start of the policy$200,000$4,000 deposit
Actual employee payroll for the year$260,000$5,200
Plus one subcontractor with no certificate$40,000$800
Audited total$300,000$6,000
Additional premium billed$100,000 over the estimate$2,000

What this means for you: $1,200 of that bill comes from real growth, because the company hired a third carpenter mid-year and never updated the estimate. The other $800 comes from a missing piece of paper, and that part can often be fixed.

If the owner produces a valid certificate showing the subcontractor was insured for the whole job, the audited total can drop to $260,000 and the bill to $1,200.

The math runs the other way too. Had payroll come in at $150,000, the audited premium would be $3,000 and the company would be due up to $1,000 back. Check whether your policy has a minimum premium, which can limit a refund.

What can you do if the audit is wrong?

Auditors work quickly from the records they are given, and mistakes happen. You have the right to question the result.

Start by asking for the audit worksheet, which shows the figures and classifications used. Compare it line by line with your own records and look for the usual errors:

  • Payroll from outside the policy dates
  • Overtime counted in full where your policy's rules call for an adjustment
  • Clerical or sales staff placed in a higher-risk classification
  • Insured subcontractors counted because a certificate was missing or expired
  • Owners or officers included when they should have been excluded, or the reverse
  • Sales that should not count, such as sales tax collected

Then follow these steps.

  1. Dispute it in writing, quickly. State exactly which figures are wrong and why.
  2. Attach proof. Certificates, payroll reports, job descriptions and tax filings carry more weight than explanations.
  3. Use the insurer's dispute procedure. Under Texas Insurance Code Section 521.005, insurers must give policyholders a brief written notice of the suggested procedure to follow in a dispute about a claim or premium. It is usually with your policy documents.
  4. Pay what you agree you owe. Ask the insurer how to handle the disputed part while it is under review.
  5. Escalate if needed. If you cannot resolve it, you can file a complaint with the Texas Department of Insurance.

What happens if you ignore the audit or understate your payroll?

Ignoring the notice does not make the audit go away. Insurers commonly complete it without you by estimating your exposure, and the estimate is rarely in your favor. An unpaid audit bill can follow you when you try to renew or move to another insurance company.

Understating payroll on purpose is more serious, particularly on workers' compensation. A Texas Department of Insurance checklist citing Labor Code Section 406.008 notes that a workers' compensation policy may be canceled on 10 days' notice for misrepresentation of the payroll used in calculating premium. Under Insurance Code Chapter 2051, a policyholder who commits a violation described in that chapter and pays less premium as a result is liable to the insurer for the difference, plus reasonable interest and attorney's fees.

One more rule is easy to miss when money is tight. The Texas Department of Insurance says you cannot charge your employees for workers' compensation coverage, so an audit bill is not something to pass along through paychecks.

How do you avoid a surprise next year?

A few habits turn the audit into a small adjustment.

  1. Estimate honestly at the start. A low estimate does not lower your premium. It only moves part of the bill to the end of the term.
  2. Report changes during the year. New hires, a big contract or a second location are reasons to ask for the estimate to be revised mid-term.
  3. Collect certificates before work begins. Make it part of how you hire every subcontractor.
  4. Separate your payroll. Track clerical, sales and field work separately, and keep overtime as its own line.
  5. Keep records by policy year. If your policy runs from June to June, your calendar-year reports will not match it.
  6. Set money aside when you are growing. If revenue is well ahead of plan, the audit will be too.
  7. Review the classifications at renewal. If the work you do has changed, the codes on the policy should change with it.

Understanding what goes into the rate helps as well. See what drives the cost of business insurance. Audits come up in specialty lines too, including garage liability and garagekeepers insurance and trucking insurance, and they apply whether or not you operate as an LLC, as we note in does a Texas LLC still need business insurance.

How Assured Insurance Group helps

Assured Insurance Group helps business owners in Flower Mound, Plano, Garland and across Dallas–Fort Worth with commercial insurance. If you have an audit notice or a bill you do not understand, bring it with your policy, and we will walk through your current coverage and your options with you. You can visit our Flower Mound office, email info@assuredinsgroup.com, or read more on our commercial insurance page. To review your coverage before the next term, request a quote or call 214-222-5234.

Get a quote (214) 222-5234

Questions people ask next

Can I refuse a premium audit?

The right to examine your books and records is written into auditable policies, so refusing is a breach of the policy conditions. Insurers commonly respond by estimating your exposure at a higher figure and billing on that basis, and an unresolved audit can make it hard to renew or to buy coverage elsewhere. Cooperating and correcting errors is nearly always the cheaper path.

How long after the policy ends does the audit happen?

The Texas Department of Insurance says the audit usually takes place after the policy expires, though it can also happen during the term. The exact timing and the deadline for supplying records are set by your policy and your insurance company. Look for an audit notice by mail or email in the weeks after expiration and answer it promptly.

Do I still get audited if I cancel the policy early?

Usually yes. The audit measures your actual exposure for the time the policy was in force, so a canceled policy is audited for the months it ran. If you switched insurance companies, expect a final audit from the old one. Keep payroll and sales records split by date so the period can be separated cleanly.

Is the owner's pay included in audited payroll?

It depends on the type of policy, the type of entity and the rules that apply to that line of coverage. Owners, partners and officers are often treated differently from ordinary employees, and some can be included or excluded by choice on a workers' compensation policy. Ask how each owner is treated before the policy starts, so the estimate and the audit use the same rule.

Can I pay an audit bill in installments?

That is up to the insurance company. An additional premium from an audit is normally due in full by the date on the invoice, but some insurers will agree to a payment arrangement if you ask before the due date. Leaving the bill unpaid can affect your current policy and your ability to renew, so raise the question early.

Does a premium audit affect my rate next year?

The audit itself changes the premium for the term that just ended. It also gives the insurer better figures for the renewal, so if your payroll or sales grew, expect the new estimate to start higher. Your claims history and classification affect the rate separately. A corrected classification found at audit can carry forward to future terms.

Sources and further reading

General information for Texas readers, current as of August 2026. It is not legal, tax or insurance advice. Your coverage depends on the wording of your own policy.

More commercial insurance guides

Get a quote

Have this checked on your own policy.

Send the basics or your declarations page. We will go through what you have and what your options are.

Ali RizviInsurance Advisor, Assured Insurance Group
Call (214) 222-5234

Get a quote for commercial insurance

We reply by phone or email with your options.

Or call (214) 222-5234. See our privacy policy.

CallGet a quote